Estimated reading time: 10 minutes
By The MakeProgress AI Team 🟪
Published: November 18, 2024
Are you staring at a blank screen, trying to write meaningful math report card comments? You're not alone. We've done the research and implemented best practices so you can save time and get back to what you do best - teach!
Without a framework, writing report card comments can become overwhelming. It's challenging to craft meaningful, personalized feedback for each student's math progress — especially if you don't have ready-to-use templates, AI tools, or a systematic approach to student assessment.
To make writing your comments easier, I've assembled a comprehensive guide of essential components. I've also created several research-validated comment templates where you can simply fill in your observations while maintaining professional standards and encouraging student growth.
Before we get into, what is some research around the research of students have a growth mind set and how can we implement that into our comments for math report cards?
Carol Dweck and her colleagues conducted a nationwide study of 10th-grade students in Chile, which provided significant insights into growth mindset and math achievement:
This research demonstrates the potential impact of growth mindset on math achievement, particularly for students from disadvantaged backgrounds.Source: Claro, S., Paunesku, D., & Dweck, C. S. (2016). Growth mindset tempers the effects of poverty on academic achievement. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 113(31), 8664-8668. Link to study
Recent research has highlighted the impact of growth mindsets on academic achievement among K-12 students. A meta-analysis of 273 independent samples involving 365,915 students found a correlation between growth mindset and academic success (r = 0.10). This effect was stronger for students facing challenges, such as those from low socioeconomic backgrounds (Sisk et al., 2018). While growth mindset interventions are popular in educational setting, fostering a growth mindset can enhance motivation and resilience, ultimately contributing to better academic outcomes.
Source: Sisk, V. F., Burgoyne, A. P., Sun, J., & Tuck, J. (2018). To what extent and under what circumstances are growth mindsets important to academic achievement? A meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 144(4), 406-447. Link to study
Now we know the importance of a growth mindset, now let's implement a framework teachers can use!
Each effective comment for developing math students should include:
Copy
[Opening Statement] + [Need Statement] + [Goal Statement] + [Strategy] + [Parent Support]
Example: [Name] is beginning to develop multiplication skills. They need additional practice with basic facts up to 5x5. Moving forward, the goal is to build confidence through daily practice. Using multiplication games and flashcards has shown promise in class. Parents can support learning by practicing facts for 10 minutes each day using provided materials.
❌ Don't use:
✅ Instead use:
(feel free to copy and paste these for your report card comments)
(Scroll further below for proficient student templates)
Template 1:
[Name] is beginning to develop skills in mental math calculations. [Pronoun] needs to work on improving [pronoun] ability to perform calculations quickly and accurately. Moving forward, the goal is to practice mental math daily using fun, interactive tools like flashcards or math games. This practice can help build confidence and speed in calculations. Parents can support [Name] by encouraging practice at home and providing positive reinforcement as progress is observed.
Template 2:
[Name] is beginning to develop skills in mental math calculations. [Pronoun] needs to focus on practicing quick addition and subtraction to boost [pronoun] confidence and accuracy. Moving forward, the goal is to incorporate daily exercises to improve [pronoun] mental math skills. Practicing at home with fun math games can greatly support [pronoun] progress. Parents might consider setting aside time each day for these activities, using simple problems that can gradually increase in difficulty. [Name] has shown determination, and with continued practice, [pronoun] will make significant improvements in [pronoun] mental math abilities.
Template 3:
[Name] is beginning to work on mental math calculations. Moving forward, the goal is to practice these calculations regularly at school and home to build confidence and speed. Currently, [Name] needs help with basic arithmetic operations in [pronoun] head. Future learning objectives include improving [pronoun] ability to add, subtract, multiply, and divide mentally. Utilizing flashcards or mental math apps could be beneficial. Additionally, parents are encouraged to engage [Name] in daily practice by asking simple math-related questions in everyday situations.
Template 1
[Name] is beginning to understand basic addition and subtraction concepts. [Pronoun] needs to focus on recognizing numbers and using simple strategies like counting on fingers to solve problems. Moving forward, the goal is to practice these skills daily at home, using real-life examples to make learning engaging. Providing support with visual aids, such as number lines, can help [Name] gain more confidence in math. Questions parents might have could be about how to support at home, so suggesting games or apps that reinforce math skills could be beneficial.
Template 2
[Name] is beginning to understand basic addition and needs to improve on subtraction. Moving forward, [Pronoun] goal is to practice adding numbers within 20 to build confidence. At home, support with simple subtraction exercises will help [Pronoun] progress. To support [Name]'s advancement in mathematics, using visual aids like number lines or counters can make addition and subtraction more concrete. [Name]'s parents might wonder how to help; practicing math facts regularly will boost [Pronoun] accuracy and speed. While [Name] is developing [Pronoun] addition skills, encouragement and positive reinforcement will greatly benefit [Pronoun] learning journey.
Template 3
[Name] is beginning to grasp basic addition and subtraction concepts. [Pronoun] needs to continue practicing with smaller numbers to build confidence. At home, playing simple math games or using flashcards could be helpful. Moving forward, the goal is to strengthen [Pronoun] understanding of number sentences, so [Pronoun] can apply these skills in solving problems. [Name] might need additional support in recognizing the relationship between addition and subtraction, which can be achieved through more practice and visual aids like number lines. Parents might consider dedicating a few minutes each day to practice these skills.
Template 1
[Name] is beginning to grasp the basics of fractions, focusing on understanding simple terms like "halves" and "quarters." [Pronoun] needs to improve on accurately representing these fractions using visual aids, such as fraction circles or bars, to better visualize the concept. Moving forward, the goal is to engage [Name] in practical activities, such as using manipulatives or fraction puzzles, to see fractions in action. Parents may find it helpful to relate fractions to everyday tasks, such as organizing items into equal groups, to make learning more intuitive.
Template 2
[Name] is almost able to work with simple fractions and is developing [Pronoun] understanding of parts of a whole. [Pronoun] continues to benefit from visual aids, such as pie charts or fraction strips, which are helping [Pronoun] see the relationship between different fractions. Moving forward, [Name] needs to focus on comparing fractions and gradually increase the complexity, starting with thirds and fifths. Parents can help by incorporating creative hands-on projects, such as building models or dividing shapes, to reinforce [Pronoun] learning in a practical way.
Template 3
[Name] is proficient in identifying and using basic fractions in everyday contexts. [Pronoun] can recognize halves and quarters and describe them in relation to visual representations or real-world objects. [Name] is ready to move on to comparing fractions with different denominators. Providing [Pronoun] with opportunities to solve real-life problems, such as working on math challenges or exploring fraction word problems, can further enhance [Pronoun] skills. To support this growth, parents might involve [Name] in tasks that naturally incorporate fractions, such as organizing equal groups or measuring for simple projects.
Template 4
[Name] demonstrates proficiency in several areas of mathematics but needs to focus on strengthening fraction skills. [Pronoun] is almost able to solve basic fraction problems but continues to find complex fractions challenging. Moving forward, [Name] should focus on improving fraction understanding through practice at home, such as using fraction flashcards or engaging in activities that involve visualizing fractions. Consider additional support resources such as tutoring or educational apps that offer fraction exercises. With continued effort and support, [Name] can achieve a stronger grasp of fractions.
Template 5
[Name] is able to understand key mathematical concepts and demonstrates a strong ability in problem-solving. However, [Pronoun] needs to improve [Pronoun] understanding of fractions. Moving forward, the goal is to focus on recognizing and comparing fractions, as well as understanding their equivalent forms. Practicing fraction games and using visual aids at home can be helpful. With continued support both at school and at home, [Name] can strengthen [Pronoun] skills in this area.
Template 6
[Name] is able to grasp mathematical concepts quickly and often demonstrates a strong understanding of various topics covered in class. However, [Pronoun] needs to focus on developing a stronger understanding of fractions. Moving forward, the goal is to improve [Pronoun] ability to solve fraction problems independently.
To support [Name]'s development in fractions:
With continued effort and support, [Name] will be able to improve [Pronoun] proficiency in fractions.
Template 1
[Name] is beginning to grasp division concepts but needs to improve in long division. To advance, [pronoun] should come to class prepared and focused, which will aid in understanding and retention. Regular practice at home, using educational tools or games, can reinforce these skills. Parents can support [Name] by setting a dedicated study time and providing resources that make learning engaging.
Template 2
[Name]'s understanding of long division is developing, but more effort is needed. Improving class preparation and maintaining focus during lessons will help [pronoun] absorb concepts more effectively. Practicing division at home, with guidance or using math apps, can strengthen skills. Encouragement from parents, focusing on consistency and motivation, will support [Name]'s progress.
Template 3
[Name] is showing initial comprehension of division but needs to enhance focus and preparation, especially for long division. Attending class with completed homework and an attentive mindset will facilitate better learning. Additional practice at home, with supportive resources like flashcards, can aid [Name]'s skill development. Parents can assist by creating a study-friendly environment and celebrating [Name]'s improvements.
Template 4
[Name] is beginning to understand division basics but needs to focus more on long division. By coming to class better prepared and concentrating during lessons, [pronoun] can improve [pronoun] skills. At home, consistent practice with division problems will reinforce what [pronoun] has learned. Parents can support [Name] by creating a routine with educational resources like apps or flashcards to make learning engaging.
Template 5
[Name] is starting to grasp the concept of long division, though [pronoun] requires more effort to reach expected proficiency levels. Attending classes prepared and maintaining focus during lessons are essential for [pronoun] progress. Practicing division at home, with parents setting a designated study time, can help build [pronoun] confidence and understanding.
Template 1
[Name] is beginning to develop foundational math skills. To help [pronoun] improve, focusing on basic arithmetic operations at school and home can be beneficial. Currently, [Name] shows a need for support in understanding mathematical concepts such as addition and subtraction. Moving forward, the goal is to reinforce these areas through practice and hands-on activities. Engaging [Name] in interactive math games and using visual aids can enhance understanding and retention. Parents might wonder how to best support [Name]; consistent practice at home and encouragement when attempting math problems can significantly boost confidence and skill development.
Template 2
[Name] is beginning to develop [pronoun] understanding of basic math concepts. [Pronoun] needs to work on grasping foundational skills such as addition and subtraction. Moving forward, the goal is to strengthen these skills through additional practice both at school and at home. [Name] would benefit from support tools such as math games or tutoring to enhance [pronoun] learning experience. Parents may wonder how to assist; simple daily practice with flashcards or involving math in daily activities could be beneficial.
Template 3
[Name] is at the early stages of developing foundational math skills, particularly in addition and subtraction. To advance, [pronoun] would benefit from consistent reinforcement of these concepts both in the classroom and at home. Using hands-on tools like manipulatives or interactive games can support [Name]'s learning process. Parents can assist by setting aside time for regular practice and encouraging [Name] with positive reinforcement, helping to build [pronoun] confidence in math.
Mental math, division, addition and subtraction
Template 1
[Name] demonstrates a strong understanding of mathematical concepts in Grade 5. [Pronoun] is proficient in subtraction and is ready to move on to more complex problems. While [pronoun] has mastered subtraction, [pronoun] could set a goal to enhance [pronoun] skills in mental math. With continued practice and support, [Name] can advance in tackling more challenging mental calculations. Parents might consider using everyday situations to help [Name] practice mental math at home, like calculating change during shopping.
Template 2
[Name] is able to understand foundational concepts in mathematics, particularly excelling in mental math, where [pronoun] achieved an A. [Pronoun] consistently demonstrates skill in problem-solving and can calculate mentally with accuracy. Moving forward, [pronoun] goal will be to apply these mental math skills in more complex problem scenarios. To support [Name] further, engaging in math-related games at home can help reinforce [pronoun] understanding. Parents may wonder how to best aid [Name]'s learning; one effective method is through daily practice of math problems to reinforce [pronoun] skills and improve [pronoun] speed.
Template 3
[Name] demonstrated excellent proficiency in addition, achieving an A. [Pronoun] shows a solid understanding of concepts and is able to solve problems accurately and with confidence. Moving forward, [Name] can focus on enhancing [pronoun] skills in subtraction to balance [pronoun] mathematical abilities. It would be beneficial for [Name] to practice subtraction exercises at home, using flashcards or engaging math games to reinforce these skills. Supporting [Name] with additional practice will help [pronoun] continue to excel and become more confident in all areas of mathematics. Parents may notice [Name]'s enthusiasm for math, and encouraging [pronoun] with additional real-life problem-solving tasks could foster [pronoun] interest further.
Template 4
[Name] is able to solve subtraction problems with ease, demonstrating a strong command of this area. Moving forward, [pronoun] goal will be to enhance [pronoun] mental math abilities, as this will further support [pronoun] mathematical development. At home, practicing quick mental calculations can be beneficial. Parents might wonder how they can support [Name] further; engaging in interactive math games that emphasize mental math could be a great resource.
Template 5
[Name] is beginning to understand key arithmetic concepts, specifically in multiplication. [Pronoun] has demonstrated excellent skills in subtraction, achieving an A in this area. Moving forward, the goal is to enhance [pronoun] mental math abilities. Practicing at home using real-life scenarios, like calculating change during shopping, can further support [pronoun] progress. Encouraging [Name]'s curiosity and providing additional resources, such as math games or puzzles, can also be beneficial.
Template 6
[Name] has shown great progress in mathematics this semester. [Pronoun] is creatively able to tackle complex subtraction problems and can independently apply strategies to find accurate solutions. Moving forward, [pronoun] goal will be to enhance [pronoun] mental math skills, allowing for more efficient calculations. [Name]'s ability to understand mathematical concepts will be further supported by regular practice with mental math challenges at home. Parents may wonder how they can help; incorporating math games and daily mental math exercises could enhance [pronoun] speed and confidence. Keep up the excellent work in subtraction!
Template 7
[Name] is making promising progress in mathematics, especially in mental math where [pronoun] received an A. [Pronoun] is able to solve problems quickly and accurately, demonstrating proficiency in this area. Moving forward, the goal is to continue strengthening [pronoun] problem-solving strategies, particularly in subtraction, where there is room for growth. Encouraging [Name] to practice subtraction problems at home will help reinforce [pronoun] learning. Parents might find it helpful to use everyday situations, such as shopping scenarios, to practice these skills collaboratively.
Template 8
[Name] is able to perform addition and subtraction with confidence. [Pronoun] creatively applies [pronoun] mental math skills to solve complex problems efficiently. Moving forward, [Name]'s goal will be to continue challenging [pronoun]self with mental math exercises at both school and home to enhance [pronoun] proficiency. Parents might consider incorporating daily mental math activities, such as quick calculations during errands, to support [Name]'s continued growth.
Functions
Template 1
[Name] demonstrates an exceptional understanding of Advanced Functions, specifically in [pronoun] ability to creatively handle Polynomial Functions. [Pronoun] can continue to explore complex scenarios involving polynomial equations with ease. Moving forward, [Name]'s goal will be to further challenge [pronoun]self by applying [pronoun] knowledge to solve real-world problems, enhancing [pronoun] analytical skills. To support [pronoun] growth, engaging in advanced problem-solving tasks and mathematical competitions could be beneficial. Parents may want to encourage [Name] to explore math-related extracurricular activities to maximize [pronoun] potential.
Template 2
[Name] demonstrates a strong understanding of rational functions, consistently showing [pronoun] ability to analyze and interpret complex expressions with precision. [Pronoun] is able to identify asymptotes, intercepts, and other key features of graphs, demonstrating readiness to move on to explore more challenging applications of these concepts. [Name] is encouraged to apply [pronoun] knowledge to real-world contexts, which will further deepen [pronoun] comprehension and enhance [pronoun] analytical skills. Parents and caregivers can support [Name] by engaging [pronoun] in discussions about how rational functions appear in various fields such as engineering and physics, promoting practical understanding and appreciation of these mathematical concepts.
Template 3
[Name] is proficient in [pronoun] understanding of Rational Functions, demonstrating a strong ability to analyze and deconstruct various expressions accurately. [Pronoun] can solve complex problems by applying appropriate mathematical strategies and is ready to extend [pronoun] skills by exploring more advanced applications to real-world scenarios. Continued engagement with challenging problems will help [Name] deepen [pronoun] understanding and creativity in mathematical thinking. Moving forward, a goal could be to explore the impact of transformations on these functions.
Template 4
[Name] is able to creatively solve problems involving exponential and logarithmic functions. [Pronoun] consistently demonstrates proficiency in understanding and applying complex concepts, and is ready to move on to exploring real-life applications of these functions. Moving forward, [Name]'s goal will be to deepen [pronoun] understanding of these applications to enhance [pronoun] mathematical reasoning and problem-solving skills. Support at home could involve discussing everyday scenarios where these concepts are used, such as in sound intensity or compound interest calculations, to further solidify [pronoun] learning.
Template 5
[Name] demonstrates a strong ability to apply advanced mathematical concepts related to Calculus and Vectors, particularly in the area of Limits and Continuity. [Pronoun] is able to analyze complex problems and find solutions efficiently. Moving forward, [pronoun] goal will be to explore more applications of Derivatives, focusing on connecting theory with real-world situations. Encouraging [Name] to engage in projects that require problem-solving skills will further enhance [pronoun] understanding. Parents can support [Name] by discussing how calculus applies to various careers, providing a practical context to [pronoun] studies.
Template 6
[Name] consistently demonstrates proficiency in Calculus and Vectors. [Pronoun] is able to understand and apply limits and continuity effectively. Additionally, [Name] shows strong capabilities with derivatives and their applications, suggesting readiness to tackle more advanced topics. Moving forward, [pronoun] goal will be to explore integrals and their applications more deeply, which will enhance [pronoun] overall calculus understanding. Encouraging additional practice with integrals at home will further support [Name]'s learning progress.
Template 7
[Name] is able to apply advanced functions to solve complex real-world problems, demonstrating strong analytical skills and mathematical understanding. [Pronoun] can creatively manipulate polynomial and rational functions, showcasing a deep comprehension of their properties and applications. Moving forward, [Name]'s goal will be to continue honing [pronoun] innovative approaches while exploring the vast connections between different function types, further enhancing [pronoun] problem-solving abilities. Collaborating with peers on challenging projects and exploring additional mathematical resources will support [pronoun] continued growth.
Template 8
[Name] has demonstrated a strong understanding of Advanced Functions, particularly in the area of Polynomial Functions. [Pronoun] is proficient in solving complex equations and can effectively apply transformations to functions, showcasing readiness to tackle more challenging mathematical problems. To continue [pronoun] advancement, [Name] can focus on exploring combinations and inverses of functions. At home, [pronoun] could benefit from additional practice in real-life applications, which will help solidify [pronoun] comprehension of abstract mathematical concepts.
Template 9
[Name] demonstrates a proficient grasp of advanced functions, particularly in the unit of polynomial functions. [Pronoun] is able to analyze and describe the characteristics of these functions, showcasing [pronoun] ability to confidently articulate solutions. Moving forward, [Name] is ready to explore more complex transformations of functions, further developing [pronoun] understanding through creative problem-solving. [Pronoun] ability to connect polynomial functions to real-world applications is commendable, and [pronoun] can benefit from exploring deeper into rational and exponential functions. Continual practice with these will not only broaden [pronoun] mathematical understanding but will also sharpen [pronoun] analytical skills, both crucial for future studies in calculus and beyond. [Name] excels at utilizing available resources to independently solve problems, and [pronoun] can continue this approach by diversifying [pronoun] practice exercises to include a range of function transformations.
Template 10
[Name] has shown exemplary proficiency in the Advanced Functions course. [Pronoun] is able to skillfully manipulate Polynomial Functions, demonstrating a deep understanding of their properties and behaviors. [Name] can effortlessly tackle problems involving Rational Functions, exhibiting creativity and independence in [pronoun] approach. Moving forward, [Name] is ready to explore more complex applications of Exponential and Logarithmic Functions, as [pronoun] has creatively mastered the foundational concepts. [Pronoun] ability to integrate Trigonometric Functions into broader mathematical contexts also highlights [pronoun] readiness to advance to more abstract mathematical challenges.
Template 11
[Name] is able to creatively handle complex trigonometric functions and demonstrates exceptional skill in applying transformations of functions. [Pronoun] can continue to deepen [pronoun] understanding by exploring the real-world applications of these mathematical concepts. Moving forward, [pronoun] goal will be to apply these skills in new contexts and share insights with peers during collaborative projects.
Template 12
[Name] is creatively able to understand and apply the principles of Trigonometric Functions, consistently demonstrating proficiency in solving complex problems with precision. Moving forward, [Name]'s goal will be to deepen [pronoun] understanding by exploring more advanced applications of transformations of functions in real-world scenarios. To support [pronoun] continued growth, engaging in additional practice and seeking challenging problems outside the classroom will be beneficial. Parents might wonder how to best support this progress at home, and encouraging [Name]'s curiosity in exploring mathematical concepts in everyday situations can enhance [pronoun] learning experience.
More specific templates!
Template 1: Derivatives
[Name] demonstrates an exceptional understanding of derivatives and their applications, effectively solving complex problems and exploring real-world scenarios. [Pronoun] can analyze and interpret critical points, providing insightful analysis in solutions. Moving forward, [Name]'s goal will be to delve deeper into integrals and their implications in various fields, enhancing [pronoun] analytical skills.
Template 2: Integrals
[Name] demonstrates a strong proficiency in integrals and their applications, showcasing the ability to solve intricate problems and connect mathematical principles to real-world scenarios such as area and accumulation. Moving forward, [pronoun] is encouraged to explore advanced applications of integrals in fields like physics or economics, which will broaden [pronoun] analytical capabilities.
Template 3: Vectors in Two Dimensions
[Name] has shown proficiency in vectors in two dimensions, effectively applying vector concepts to solve mathematical and real-world problems. [Pronoun] demonstrates readiness to tackle more complex applications of vectors, such as in physics or engineering contexts. Moving forward, engaging in projects that require vector analysis will support [pronoun] growth and deepen [pronoun] understanding.
Template 4: Statistics and Data Analysis
[Name] excels in statistics and data analysis, consistently demonstrating [pronoun] ability to interpret data accurately and apply statistical methods to solve real-world problems. [Pronoun] is ready to advance to probability distributions and statistical inference, which will enhance [pronoun] understanding of data-driven decision-making. Encouraging [Name] to engage in data analysis projects can provide valuable practical experience.
Template 5: Trigonometry
[Name] is proficient in trigonometry, confidently solving problems involving trigonometric functions and identities. [Pronoun] is ready to explore advanced trigonometric applications, such as navigation and architectural design. Moving forward, participating in projects that require practical uses of trigonometry will strengthen [pronoun] skills and broaden [pronoun] perspective.
Template 6: Financial Mathematics
[Name] demonstrates strong skills in financial mathematics, effectively solving problems related to interest calculations, loans, and financial planning. [Pronoun] is ready to explore more complex financial models and investment strategies, which will further develop [pronoun] understanding of real-world financial applications.
Template 7: Fractions and Applications
[Name] demonstrates an excellent grasp of fractions and their applications. [Pronoun] confidently adds, subtracts, multiplies, and divides fractions to solve a variety of problems. To challenge [pronoun] further, [Name] can explore real-world problems involving fractions, such as cooking or crafting, to apply [pronoun] understanding in practical scenarios.
Template 8: Geometry and Spatial Reasoning
[Name] excels in geometry, particularly in identifying and classifying shapes based on their properties. [Pronoun] ability to understand angles and calculate perimeters and areas showcases [pronoun] strong spatial reasoning skills. Moving forward, [Name] can enhance [pronoun] learning by exploring more complex geometric challenges, such as designing simple architectural models using [pronoun] knowledge of shapes.
Template 9: Data Management and Interpretation
[Name] shows a keen interest in data management and interpretation by effectively organizing and analyzing data sets. [Pronoun] can create accurate graphs and draw insightful conclusions from the data presented. To build on [pronoun] proficiency, [Name] could work on projects that involve real-world data collection, such as conducting a class survey and presenting the results.
Template 10: Patterns and Relationships
[Name] has a strong understanding of number patterns and relationships, using [pronoun] skills to solve equations and identify sequences with ease. [Pronoun] demonstrates critical thinking when approaching mathematical problems. Encouraging [Name] to participate in math clubs or competitions could provide further opportunities to explore and enhance [pronoun] mathematical abilities.
Q: What's the ideal length for math report card comments?A: Research indicates 3-4 sentences optimize parent comprehension and action-taking. Focus on specific progress, challenges, and next steps.
Q: What if a student shows minimal improvement?A: Focus on effort metrics and implement research-backed intervention strategies. Document small wins in specific skill areas and provide clear, achievable next steps.
Remember, effective math progress report comments aren't about fancy language—they're about clear communication that drives improvement. Use these research-backed strategies to save time while making a real difference in student achievement.
Take the next step: Download our complete guide and transform your report card writing process today.